May 19, 2012

When motherhood takes a hit

by Catherine Anderson

The following post, came from a phone call I had with a dear friend who is going through a secretive, and very painful period of not feeling as connected to her son, as she always dreamed she would.  I am going to leave out specifics, to protect her identity, but what I hope my post here addresses is more of a universal.

While talking to her I was struck again by all the silence and shame we have around idealized visions of what it is to be maternal, let alone “the perfect mom” (which we know doesn’t exist).  What do we do with those feelings of disappointment when motherhood and our little angel aren’t what we were banking on? Is it just a phase sometimes? What happens when you fear it may be more of a life long disconnect?

This is the example I shared with her.  I imagine many of us, have our own.

A few nights ago  Marcel, Sam, and I were running a race on the little path behind our friend’s cottage.(OK it was to the outhouse if you must know.)  I was carrying Marcel (2.5) and Sam (closing in on 6) was losing. To make it worse, he was not able to pass us-the path was too small…

You know where this is going? Marcel and I were pushed from behind, and hard, into the ground- and to add deep worry to injury, even as we hit the ground, Sam just kept running.

Marcel’s back was whacked on a log and had the wind knocked out of him. Both my knees were scraped bloody, and sizzled in pain.  After being certain Marcel was not more badly hurt, my thought; Sam is ruthless, or worse.

I don’t know what hurt worse, that thought or my knees.

After grabbing Sam by the arms, and explaining how dangerous that was, and begging for some kind of why, and somehow not yelling, I regrouped, and sent him into his room without desert.

Everyone was freaked out. Probably he more than us. He had never physically hurt me before, other than a scratch, or a fat lip from a baseball thrown too hard.  When I came in to help him get his pjs on he just crawled into my lap and sobbed. His way of letting go. He is so strong physically and can’t control it always. To him it was a game, to me it was an attack. That’s where I feel like I drop the ball in the good mom department.

He is competitive to a fault, was stuck, and maybe mad inside about Marcel being the baby, and in my arms, and maybe even that he is biologically related to me.  Mad about leaving preschool soon, and going to kindergarten. Mad that he is not the best swimmer in the world, even after a day in the lake. Mad that there is no dad in this family unit, or just mad that he couldn’t get past me, plain and simple.

My friend’s dad, a retired elementary principal for forty years, said he thought Sam was trying to “be the little man” since I am not married/partnered. This is a hard role for him to manage, and he is acting out. I had never thought of that, and am not sure what to make of it, but considering my live in brother had been away for a few weeks, it makes sense in a way.

Bottom line: I am mother. Safe. Strong. Invincible. I should just fly out of the way when I am pushed, not fall!

My feelings of failing him in my rearing, not being the “right” mom, not being able to love ( that behavior) and always down deep worrying about what is going to happen as he gets older and STRONGER and could really hurt me come up often.

Then I remind myself that I am not alone. Gazillion moms with little boys-adopted or not-have struggles with their boys too. They doubt themselves too. They wish it were easier. They wish they knew what they could differently, to just get them to simmer down, or listen to the reuqest the first time around.

I deconstruct motherhood daily.  I try to remove the layers that the Brady Bunch or the Cosby Show heaped  on my young girl mind and what my own parents did not. Those moms never yelled, and always seemed to have agreeable, and reasonable children, without anger issues, or button pushing as their number one hobby, after tackling their brother when mom wasn’t looking.

On good days, I see myself as a champion of an at times very serious, angry, thoughtful, physically gifted and loving and if only-he-knew-how-loved child.

I’ll move mountains for him to be hopeful and seen on this planet. That is my understanding of why I am here for him most days. Marcel is a completely other story. He is a pat of warm butter melting on toast for the most part for the moment. That will shift, but temperamentally he and I are much better suited. I never knew that a parent could have a temperament that was not an ideal match for their child. You don’t learn that in high school, or college. There is so much that parenthood reveals only through experience. So much that I would have suffered so much less over if someone had just said; you may not be a great match temperamentally, but that doesn’t mean you won’t have a tremendously powerful bond. It just takes more work, and its worth it.

Today we spent the day swimming at a lake. Hours and hours of it. Every once in a while I caught Sam looking at my grotesque boo-boos and looking away. Part of me wanted to make them go away, part of me wanted to yell--You know they sting!!!! Then the grown up in me, climbed up onto the dock next to him and did a giant cannon ball when he counted to three. When he asked out friend on the beach who made a bigger splash, he answered just right; It was a tie!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Kirtsy
  • Tumblr
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Digg
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Print
  • email
  • PDF
  • RSS

Guest Authors

We love publishing diverse articles from diverse men and women. If you have something to say and would like your voice heard on We of Hue, please head here to submit and article or here to inquire about joining our team of talented regular authors.

More Posts

  • http://momontherise.com Kristina Brooke

    Hi Catherine. As much as I believe that all moms (and maybe to an extent most dads) have this issue, as I read your piece I can’t help but wonder if your feelings towards your son are too analytical. And maybe I am getting this from more than just this post but I would be disingenuous if I did not speak to you in the same way that I would any other mom whose words struck me.

    You mention Sam’s strength and anger often in your writing and I would not be honest if I did not admit that my stomach knots each time you do. The racial implication of those words are unsettling to me as Black Boys and Black Men are often criticized as being angry and violent and are stereotypically believed to possess some inhumane strength.

    Much of what you share about your son’s behavior is age-appropriate. It is not due to his race nor the fact that he is an adopted child. We often create these reasons to explain away behavior that makes us feel uncomfortable and inadvertently create children who become unnecessarily aware that these reasons exist. Why do you questions these things? What is it about your own understanding that makes these things pop into your mind?

    In addition, it is so important that you (and all parents) ask yourself if you are creating insecurities in your own child? Are you putting a lot of weight on his shoulders by adding adult meaning to childish behavior?

    And if so what can you do to change that?

    • http://mamacandtheboys.com Mama C/Catherine

      Kristina,

      I have thought about your words over and over for several days. There are so many layers to perceptions about anger and boys and adoption and boys and race and boys to uncover and debunk. There is so much work to do, in our writing, our dialogues, our blogs to move us all forward. Thank you for taking the time and care to point out what you notice as themes and repetition in my work.

      I am really looking now at my son’s behavior as being impulsive, and as both you and Tameka pointed out, behaviorally appropriate.

      I do want to clarify that the “adult meaning” I assign to his behavior is something I may do too much of here, but I am super aware to not talk to him about these things in inappropriate ways.

      Thanks again for giving me the space to explore and write about this mama journey!

  • http://teanhoneybread.blogspot.com T.Allen-Mercado

    There is so much here, both in your post Catherine, and in Kristina’s comment. Much of it resonates with me as a parent of a young man who identifies as Black, but moreover what resonates with me is this part of the sentence in bold print: “I was struck again by all the silence and shame we have around idealized visions…”

    There have been “phases” along my parenting journey where I felt detached, rejected, defeated, bitter, resentful and almost always GUILTY. The culprit? Those damn “idealized visions”. In retrospect, and with eavesdropping ears, I am now privy to the incredible job I’ve done raising my children amid the aimless, angst-filled ambling of those earlier years.

    Once a friend and I were discussing something re: family and I said, “Perception is reality…” To which she retorted, “Perception is a lie”. It gave me much pause for thought. While perception may not be entirely false-(I like to think we’re all connected to some semblance of standardized reality)- our perceptions of both the real and ideal are based almost exclusively on OUR own experiences and expectations.So much of what we need, want and expect from our children is rooted in the validation we seek as parents. Lucky (or not) for us, they’re clueless!

    To echo Kristina about age appropriate behaviors, I’d say Sam is in the throes of having big boy aspirations in a not so big body. We had our share of aggression issues between 6 and 8, although I suspect having a little brother increases the speed and intensity in which one stakes claim to the “throne”.

    I think you’ll see a marked increase in compassion, sensitivity and awareness towards both you and Marcel as he becomes less attached and more whole in his identity as an individual. The selfishness subsides and you, like him will become actual people, like friends and teachers and neighbors not just HIS mom and HIS little brother. Thanks for sharing.

    • http://mamacandtheboys.com Mama C/Catherine

      Tameka,

      Thank you for the reassuring words! I am easing up on myself, and him, and really looking at all the amazing things he is mastering! He is working so hard at being 5!

      This line; “So much of what we need, want and expect from our children is rooted in the validation we seek as parents. Lucky (or not) for us, they’re clueless! ” resonated deeply.

      It is such a help to share this adventure with so you and others who have gone before me, and have so much wisdom to share from the other side!

      Thank you!

  • http://lovesgumbo.com Love’s Gumbo

    So many things struck me when reading this article. I have a child who pushes my buttons, so I contemplate temperaments matching all the time. I struggle with not mentally scarring my child because our values are so different. Our values are different, but our behaviors are similar. This dynamic makes for a very interesting push, pull, up down, guilt-ridden, come to Jesus relationship. I just keep saying to myself that my baby is very special and that she is marked for greatness. All of this is the way it is for a reason. I am learning as I am teaching. She is teaching me to learn. I say all that to say that I understand buttoning pushing.

    I am also a recent mother to a baby son, so I am just understanding the physical strength of men and boys. My baby is very aggressive and strong, so I think about how to convey to him the need to respect me and his sisters and other women. He is an uncultivated bundle of strength and aggression, and I already talk to him and demonstrate the need to be gentle. I think it’s important for you to teach your son to respect you and to treat you special and gentle. Mothers are to be revered, and if a father is not there to show that example, you must demand it.

    Next I’ll have to admit that I had to click on who you were after reading your post because it sounded laced with fear and guilt in a classic white woman way. I was hopeful that it was something else, but I was saddened to see that it wasn’t. Before you get angry at my frankness, I want to say that this is a challenge to you to explore your deepest feelings. You obviously are not racist because adopted a black boy, but you seem to still have some very deep rooted racial feelings about black boys. My advice is not to lock up with fear, but to release and explore those feelings. You are not the devil for having them, and if you allow it all to flow through you, you will grow. Please don’t react with fear or guilt, just let it all flow. Even black mothers are afraid of their black sons because of what society tells us.

    I wishing you all the positivity in the world, and just know that you and your friend are not alone. We all struggle with being good mommies.

  • http://loveisntenough.com Julia

    Hi Love’s Gumbo,
    I really appreciate your post and wonder if you would mind if I asked you something. When you say “it sounded laced with fear and guilt in a classic white woman way,” is it mostly these parts that you mean?
    -”Sam is ruthless, or worse. I don’t know what hurt worse, that thought or my knees.”
    -”My feelings of failing him in my rearing, not being the “right” mom, not being able to love ( that behavior) and always down deep worrying about what is going to happen as he gets older and STRONGER and could really hurt me come up often.”

    Or are there other places as well where you see this white woman guilt and fear?

    I ask because I am, like Catherine, a white mother of a black boy, and if I’m missing some of that stuff in her post, it’s likely that I’m also missing it in myself. And if that’s the case, I’d want to know so that I can get down to work.

  • http://lovesgumbo.com Love’s Gumbo

    These statements:
    “…deep worrying about what is going to happen as he gets older and STRONGER and could really hurt me come up often.”

    “…and maybe mad inside about Marcel being the baby, and in my arms, and maybe even that he is biologically related to me. Mad about leaving preschool soon, and going to kindergarten. Mad that he is not the best swimmer in the world, even after a day in the lake. Mad that there is no dad in this family unit, or just mad that he couldn’t get past me, plain and simple.”

    Labeling all those emotions as “mad” signals societal labels of an angry black male. Also, being fearful of being hurt by your own son is usually a very very distant and fleeting thought, if that. Not one that mothers usually verbalize or consider unless they are fearful. Who would fear a 6 year old boy, unless someone has told you to do so.

    These are all things to explore. Him pushing her down may show that he has already picked up on her fear, and it needs to be nipped now.

  • http://loveisntenough.com Julia

    Thank you, Love’s Gumbo, for taking the time to respond. I see what you are saying, and this helps me understand Kristina’s response even more.

    Peace.

  • http://mamacandtheboys.com Mama C/Catherine

    Love’s Gumbo-

    I am not tensing in fear–which isn’t to say I am not feeling defensive. But what good does that do me?

    Adopting a Black child does not mean I am not racist. Adopting a Black child means my world was blown open from day one in just how much deep down, learned, inherited, acculturated racist thinking that is a part of who I am. In the last few years I have begun the HARD WORD of embracing that, and learning that, and unlearning that, and naming that, and showing up to be called on that.

    So thank you, and please continue to point it out to me, because I can’t point it out to myself.

    I do want to say that, I verbalize many things that many others might not choose to. Or at least that has been feedback many people over the years of my writing on the ether have shared with me. What was scary about that moment in time, was that I was running fast, had the little one in my arm, and then got pushed down hard. I didn’t know it was coming, and it scared me to think that my kid could hurt me and his brother. But he was just racing along a path, and not trying to hurt me. He wanted to win a race. He was being a boy. I was being an over analytical mom. You can call me racist in my reaction, and I will listen.

    I have had white teachers pick on my son’s behavior on the playground, and not notice when the white boys were doing the same thing. I told them I thought his behavior was being singled out, because Black boy behavior is often pathologized. Did I do the same thing? Or would I have the same “fear” if I had an older adopted white son who was “mad” at me for winning a race, while I held his biological younger brother in my arms? I’d like to think so. But is that really the point? You are talking about my language.

    My biggest fear, is not being able to do the work I need to fast enough to be the mother both my sons need and deserve in this world.

    I appreciate your time with me, and your comforting and encouraging words. Clearly I need a lot of help.

    I’d like to respond to more, but I have to get the boys OUTSIDE.

    Catherine

  • http://lovesgumbo.com Love’s Gumbo

    “My biggest fear, is not being able to do the work I need to fast enough to be the mother both my sons need and deserve in this world.”

    That is something that we all struggle with as parents because kids watch us and look to us to be great examples. Funny thing is we know that we aren’t and that causes major anxiety in us.

    Let me repeat myself. I do not think you are racist! I think you are a product of your environment and that you are a woman with courage. Focus on that courage. I know I have to when dealing with my own baby button pusher.

    Concerning verbalizing your fears, my concerns there are just that. My concerns. I make it a practice to govern my live in a way that doesn’t give energy to fear, and I projected that onto you. If you want to verbalize your fear that shouldn’t be my concern really.

    All of this is what it is. Love is still present and love beats all.

  • http://lovesgumbo.com Love’s Gumbo

    One more thing…Instead of mad I see these emotions as:

    “and maybe mad inside (jealous) about Marcel being the baby, and in my arms, and maybe even that he is biologically related to me. Mad (Sad) about leaving preschool soon, and (fearful of the unknown) going to kindergarten. Mad (frustrated) that he is not the best swimmer in the world, even after a day in the lake. Mad (confused Or embarrassed) that there is no dad in this family unit, or just mad (yeah, just mad) that he couldn’t get past me, plain and simple.

  • http://mamacandtheboys.com Mama C/Catherine

    Right on! I agree with all of the wording there, and will say that the repetition of the “mad” in that paragraph was honestly intended for the poetry in the repetition of the paragraph. I totally get that in light of the way that Black boys and Black men are often described as mad, it was a poor choice period.

    And, I do not feel that you are calling me racist. I doubt you’d spend this much time bothering with this conversation if you thought I was racist. I am saying that I have to UNLEARN decades of race imbalanced (?) assumptions, teachings, and so on.

    Like Julie, I get that I have so much work to do, and I also know that I am doing the work, and that I am a loving and present Mama who is courageous and full of imperfection.

    I love your words about the energy of fear, and how your life in a way that is not about perpetuating that. That feels like a huge lesson for me. Any suggestions for ways to help me shift to that way of thinking would be really appreciated–books? Gurus? Your blog :)

  • http://teanhoneybread.blogspot.com T.Allen-Mercado

    ::Doing the open dialog dance:: Yay Mamas!

  • Kristina Daniele

    I have been meaning to come back here and comment but was waiting for others to chime in as I worry if I change the tone of the comments and writing being that this is my project. I am so glad that others are commenting and sharing their thoughts in an intelligent way. This is the kind of dialogue that I envisioned taking place on this site and I hope that it continues with every post as we move forward.

    With that I must reiterate that it was Catherine’s use of specific terms that initally struck a cord with me. It is, for me, not a question of racism but rather a reflection of a world/society that openly fears Black boys and the Black men they become. For me it is about the keen sense of perception that children have when it comes to even the most subtle actions.

    And I wonder how much of Sam’s actions are in response to a sense of awkwardness that he may feel. All parents inadvertently encourage behavior from our children based on our own personal understandings no matter how off that understanding may be. I think we owe it to ourselves and our children to examine these perceptions before they become reality.

  • http://lovesgumbo.com Love’s Gumbo

    @Mama C try writings by Michael Beckwith, Deepak Chopra. Also you might try the Law of Attraction and “As a Woman Thinketh.”

  • Pingback: Will I ever learn? « Mama C and the Boys

  • Lesia

    I want to suggest something for Catherine, as another mother who tends to be overanalytical. What I have learned from my children, aged 8, 4, and 2, is that when they have a tantrum there’s always a good reason, as I’d suspect there is for any acting out and physical aggression, of which there is lots between the kids. They also act out against us, their parents. When I am able to ask why they’ve behaved the way they have – usually by venturing a guess and only when I’m able to remember that their anger is about their feelings of being hurt and being frustrated and not about mine, ie my hurt and frustration at not being listened to, meaning obeyed, respected, or cooperated with – they astound me with the profound simplicity of their emotional reason. What I want to do more of is listen to them and not impose my own (adult) interpretation onto the narrative that’s unfolding. It’s their story too as children who grow up in our family and not just mine as I learn to be their mother. They’re all different, and from them this is what I’ve learned about being temperamentally mismatched (with parents and with other children): even when there are differences there are similarities, and even when there are similarities there are differences and my children are better than I am at accepting and, I believe, understanding who I am and who their father is and who their siblings are in all our our complexity and with all our many contradictions.

  • Pingback: LIE Links | Love Isn't Enough - on raising a family in a colorstruck world