June 19, 2013

The fall of the gracious winner and the reflective loser

There is nothing that bothers me more than a parent who believes that their child can not engage in healthy competition for fear of losing. It’s sad really. Competition has become such a feared thing that parents will do what ever it takes to ensure that losing is a thing of the past.

Take for example the movement to reward every child with a trophy despite his or her actual level of skill/progress/contribution. As someone who played competitive sports for much of her childhood and well into her adult years, I find this to be rather appalling. When I was younger I played softball, volleyball, basketball, and I ran track. I also threw the shot put, participated in the long jump, the high jump, and in the triple jump. And while basketball volleyball and softball came somewhat naturally to me, distance running was not my forte and I was below average in jumping. The truth is that I lost some of the events in which I competed. Yet, I succeeded in others and never once did I or my mother demand that I be rewarded when my skills were not up to par. And what is wrong with that? What does that teach? I grew up knowing that in order to be rewarded for anything in life, you had to work hard, you had to show progress, and that often times there would be people who were far better at things than I. That is called character. That is called reality.

What is happening lately is that parents have decided that children are far too fragile to learn some of the most basic and necessary lessons in life. We have become a culture that celebrates mediocrity and provides children with a false sense of perfection. In essence we are creating what is rapidly becoming our own downfall. We are no longer raising individuals who were strong in character and possess the strong work ethic that once made this nation great. We are raising children who were becoming accustomed to everything being easy and to being rewarded for doing the minimal amount of work possible.

I have numerous trophies and medals that I won while participating in competitive sports. They are in my closet in a crate and serve as a reminder that if I work hard I can achieve great success. My daughter, who recently turned four, loves looking at them. One day she said to me, “Mommy, I want a trophy.” I responded, as most mothers would, by saying, “here, have one of mine.” Her response made me realize that my husband and I are doing a good job. She said, “No Mommy I want to win one of my own.”

This is the attitude that I wish to cultivate and this is the attitude that I wish more parents would pass down to their own children. This attitude. when combined with the understanding that winning isn’t everything, fosters a sense of pride and teaches children not only to be gracious winners but reflective losers as well. When we can teach children that hard work has its rewards and that no one wins all the time, then we can create children who work hard to accomplish their goals. In addition, helping children learn that they are better at some things then they are at others is a lesson that will give them confidence and strength to at least try.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Kirtsy
  • Tumblr
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Digg
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Print
  • email
  • PDF
  • RSS

Kristina Daniele

Kristina, Founder and Oz of We of Hue is one of many doing it across hues-homeschooling, wifing, mothering, and business building. She is a web designer and social media consultant with a love of building communities on line. She looks forward to intelligent conversation that is eye-opening and statement-making.

More Posts - Website

  • http://www.honeysmoke.com honeysmoke

    i agree. when these children grow up they will lose something their parents can’t control. the children will be crushed and will not be armed with what they need to bounce back. that day will truly be sad and it’s closer than we think.
    .-= honeysmoke´s last blog ..My Children’s Keeper =-.

    • http://www.kristinabrooke.org Kristina Daniele

      I have a friend who becomes so hysterical when things don’t go her way that she damn near hyperventilates. She comes from a family that never allowed her to experience failure. When she wasn’t chosen for the lead in her HS play, her dad would create such waves that she would have featured roles even when they didn’t exists. It’s a shame. I hope more parents wake up.

  • http://comfortingplace.blogspot.com Barbara

    I think you make some good points Kristina. I can see how a sheltered existence can keep a child unprepared for the real world. Although I am really not a fan of competition in general, I do think that the system of winning and losing creates room to discover one’s passion and talents. When it comes to little kids, much like the age your daughter is now, depending on the type of competition, I am a believer in the “every child should be rewarded for their efforts”, but yes, there comes a time when there must be winners and losers because it does teach lessons in dedication and growth.
    .-= Barbara´s last blog ..Poor Baby Squares =-.

    • http://www.kristinabrooke.org Kristina Daniele

      Oh yes, when children are my daughter’s age I think they should be taught the skills necessary to learn the sport or whatever it is that they are doing. My decision to homeschool my daughter came because I believe schools push kids into competition before they have had a chance to develop self-esteem. However, when 14 year olds are still getting participation trophies, something is wrong.

  • http://mamacandtheboys.com Catherine/ Mama C

    I remembered reading your post how amazing it felt, in the audience in elementary school, looking at the trophies and wondering, “is one of those for me?” It was such a thrilling filling to wonder, if I had earned it. There is a thrill there, that is contained within the scope of did I work hard, did I achieve my personal best. With five times the tables worth of trophies who feels anything? Thank you for this post.
    .-= Catherine/ Mama C´s last blog ..Everything Drawer-May =-.

  • http://lovesgumbo.com love’s Gumbo